Tuesday was my birthday and I wanted to make something yummy for my birthday. That is right, I am made my own birthday dessert (I know that my fellow food bloggers will understand this quite well). Now my first thought (of course) was to make a super fun cupcake that I hadn’t tried yet, but then I remembered these delicious mini cheesecakes that I made this past fall, and I knew that was what I wanted. The ones I made in the fall were raspberry, but for some reason I have been on a lime kick lately, so I came up with the idea of a key lime flavored cheesecake. I knew that someone somewhere had created one already and I was right. I found a recipe at Smitten Kitchen and low and behold she even made them mini like I was looking for! In her blog I also noticed she had a neat mini cheesecake pan. I had never seen one of these before and was immediately fascinated so I hopped on my favorite gadget buying site, eBay, and found one for a good deal! This pan is adorable, that is if a pan can be adorable, and it makes adorable little bite sized desserts. How perfect is that? I digress…on to the recipe.
The original recipe from Gormet, May 2002 was made for a full cheesecake and our friends over at Smitten Kitchen used half the recipe to make 12 mini cheesecakes. The recipe that I show below has been reduced and will yield 12 mini cheesecakes (with a little bit extra), that is why some of the measurements are a little odd. The original recipe also called for lime soaked mangoes to garnish the tops of the cakes, however I am not a big fan of mango so I decided to go with coconut. After reading the Smitten Kitchen blog she put the “lime in the coconut” song in my head and I couldn’t get it out. I even played the song and sang it a lot while I was baking these. That song is addicting! I also used cinnamon gram crackers in the crust as this is my favorite way to make a cheesecake crust (my super fabulous cousin Hallie gave me the idea).
These cheesecakes were fantastic! They were exactly what I had imagined a key lime flavored cheesecake would taste like. They have the perfect tangy lime flavor and the cheesecake is soft and smooth. I loved these so much I think next time I will make the whole big cheesecake!
For crust
3/4 cups fine cinnamon graham cracker crumbs
2 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted
For filling
1 (8 ounce) packages cream cheese at room temperature
1/2 cup plus 1 tablespoons sugar
1/4 cup plus 2 tablespoons fresh key lime juice (strained from about 1 1/2 lb Key limes) or bottled if you can find it
1/4 cup sour cream
1/4 teaspoon vanilla
1 tablespoons plus 1 teaspoon all-purpose flour
1/8 teaspoon salt
1 large egg and 1 egg yolk
For topping
1/2 cup chilled heavy cream
1 tablespoon sugar
1/2 cup shredded coconut
Make crust: Preheat oven to 350°F. This recipe can be made in a mini cheesecake pan or in a muffin pan with or without papers.
Stir together crumbs and butter in a bowl with a fork until combined well, divide the crumb mixture into the 12 holes of your mini cheesecake pan (or muffin cups) then press evenly onto bottom of each hole of the pan. Bake crust in middle of oven for 4-5 minutes and cool in pan on a rack.
Make filling: Reduce oven temperature to 325°F.
Beat cream cheese with an electric mixer at medium speed until fluffy, then beat in sugar. Add lime juice, sour cream, and vanilla and beat until smooth. Mix in flour and salt at low speed, scraping down side as needed, until just incorporated, then add eggs all at once and mix just until incorporated.
Pour filling onto the crusts in each hole of the pan. Bake cakes in the middle of the oven until set in center, about 25-30 minutes (be sure to watch your mini cheesecakes as they can over cook very since they are small). Cool completely in pan on a rack. (Cake will continue to set as it cools.)
Run a thin knife around edge of each cake and push up to remove from the pan.
Make topping: Place the shredded coconut in a saute pan and heat over medium heat on the stove until lightly toasted (it is important that you watch it closely as it can burn very quickly).
Beat cream with sugar in a bowl with electric mixer until it just holds stiff peaks, then spread or pipe on top of each cheesecake. Then place the toasted coconut on top of the whipped cream and enjoy your bite sized treat!
Adapted from: Smitten Kitchen





Happy birthday
Really cute cheesecakes, I just love the way they look
Great recipe, awesome pics!
Happy Birthday!! And yes… I totally “get” making your own dessert! I have to admit that I am totally spoiled as my neighbor makes cakes for her business, so I get treated rather nicely! (The chocolate raspberry is my favorite… or, maybe the coconut…)
In any case, these are simply perfect! I just purchased one of those mini cheesecake pans, but haven’t had an occasion to use it yet. This might be the way to break it in! Gorgeous pics, BTW!
This looks so fantastically fabulous! My mouth is watering!! I love finding new recipes to use my mini muffin tin because bite-sized desserts are the best. I just made mini goat cheese cheesecakes and I fell in love. Key lime is my favorite though so I am very excited to try this out! Love this post!
<3Marea
Happy Birthday! And I bet the toasted coconut on these mini cheesecakes just put you over the edge! Pure and yummy!
Happy Birthday!
I wanna try making this too, it looks so yummy!
Happy Birthday! I love your recipes. Great inspiration!! Thank you for sharing all these recipes with us. This particular one looks soooooo deliciouuuuuuuus!!!!!!
These are amazing! I totally understand making your own birthday dessert, I would rather make something I really want than try to explain to someone how to make it! These are gorgeous, and the coconut is brilliant!
Happy belated birthday! Key lime is one of my favorite flavors! These look great!
These little angels are filled with all things good! Lime and coconut married with cheesecake is the perfect way to celebrate a birthday , or in fact any day!! Wonderful choice!
Perfectly delicious looking cakes! I love little individual treats and these are on point. I applaud you making your dessert of choice for your own birthday. Happy belated…
These look so cute, I do something similar but as a one cheesecake. Between the crust and the creamcheese mixture I put pineapple. I simmer the pineapple on the stove with cinnamon until it’s dense and most of the juice is boiled off.
These look amazing! Such a great idea with the mini cheesecakes and toasted coconut. I will haveee to make these this week! :] Happy belated birthday!!
You are singing my tune with the lime! My favorite flavor! I’ve been eyeing up those mini cheesecake pans as well, I’ll have to head over to ebay!
These are just charming. A fabulous birthday treat.
Lime is a wonderful flavor choice.
happy belated bday! my sis-in-law loves key lime pie, so i think i’ll have to make the cheesecake version for her bday this year! looks just lovely!
Beautiful! These key lime cheesecakes look so cute and heavenly! Happy birthday to you! and Congrats on Top9 today!
Happy Birthday!!!
Those mini key lime cheesecakes look delicious! And very cute too!
Love this, it looks fantastic, I have been wanting a mini cheesecake pan and never thought to look on ebay! Thanks for sharing! Hope you have a great birthday!
How cute! I’ve been feelin’ the lime lately. :p This looks so dainty and delectable. The perfect one-biter!
Happy Birthday!! I loooooove key lime anything and especially cheesecake – yum!! Beautiful photos and I love that they are bite sized to make portion control easy!
Best,
Veronica
Oh and Congrats on Top 9!! I just buzzed you again!
I am clearly late to say happy birthday, but I will never be too late to tell you it’s DEFINITELY okay to make your own birthday cake. These look wonderful and I love individual sized desserts.
Happy belated birthday! These mine cheesecakes look delightful! And I love the pan… definitely going to have to find myself one of those.
happy belated birthday! these look wonderful! my birthday is next week and you can bet I’ll be baking my cake too
Okay, so now I totally want a mini cheesecake pan! Great recipe and pics!
These look (and sound) fantastically good!
Thank you so much! I think your blog is fabulous! I love all things cookies and cupcakes too! I look forward to sharing with you.
hi.. happy belated b’day.. just wondering where you buy the 12 hole cheesecake pans.. they look fantastic..
Thanks! It is called a “Mini Cheesecake Pan” and it is made by Norpro. I bought mine on Amazon.com.
[...] Mini Key Lime Cheesecakes From Pure And Yummy [...]
[...] 1. No Bake Lemon Curd Cheesecake Bars 2. Mini Key Lime Cheesecakes 3. Strawberry Cheesecake Cupcake 4. Dark Chocolate Pretzel Crust Mini Cheesecake SHARE & [...]
You don’t have to refrigerate the cakes like other cheese cakes?